For most cards, eBay gets the highest price but takes about 13% in fees. TCGplayer is better for lots of cheaper singles. Auction houses suit expensive vintage and graded cards. Card shops and shows pay less, but pay today with no shipping. The right place depends on what the card is worth and how much work you want to do.
Quick comparison
| Where | Best for | Fees | Speed |
|---|---|---|---|
| eBay | Most cards over $20, graded cards | 13.25% plus a per-order fee | Days to weeks |
| TCGplayer | Modern singles in bulk | 10.75% plus payment processing | Days to weeks |
| Auction houses | High-end vintage and graded | Varies by house | Weeks |
| Card shops | Fast cash, bulk | Built into a lower offer | Same day |
| Card shows | Fast cash, trades | Built into a lower offer | Same day |
eBay
eBay has the most buyers, which usually means the best prices. For trading cards, the fee is 13.25% of the total sale up to $7,500, and 2.35% on anything above that, plus $0.30 per order for sales of $10 or less or $0.40 for sales over $10, per eBay's fee page.
Good for: graded cards, vintage, anything over about $20. Watch out for: shipping costs, returns, and buyers who want to negotiate. Use tracked shipping on anything valuable.
TCGplayer
TCGplayer is built for card singles and is popular with players. The commission is 10.75%, capped at $75 per item, plus 2.5% and $0.30 for payment processing, according to TCGplayer's fee schedule.
Good for: modern singles, playable cards, selling many cards at once. Watch out for: competing on price with lots of other sellers. Listings sit at the bottom of a price-sorted list.
Auction houses
Fanatics, Goldin, Alt and Heritage handle many of the biggest Pokémon sales. The top PSA 10 sales of 2026, from 1st Edition Charizard to Legendary Collection reverse holos, mostly went through these houses. Each house sets its own seller fees and minimum consignment value, so ask before you send.
Good for: cards worth thousands, especially high-grade vintage. Watch out for: consignment timelines, which can run several weeks.
Card shops
A local shop will buy your cards on the spot. Expect offers below market, often 50 to 70% for singles they need and less for bulk. In return, there is no shipping, no listing, and no wait. Find one near you in our card shop directory.
Good for: bulk, fast cash, store credit (which is usually worth more than cash).
Card shows
Vendors at shows buy too, usually at 60 to 80% of market for raw cards and closer to market for high-demand graded cards. You can shop several vendors in an hour and take the best offer. Our guide to card shows near you covers how to sell on the floor.
Before you sell
- Know what the card is worth. Look at recent sales, not asking prices. Our guide to what your card is worth explains how.
- Check the condition honestly. Our condition guide shows how to grade a card by eye.
- Consider grading. A card worth a lot more graded can be worth sending in first. See the cost to grade.
- Do the math on fees. On a $100 card sold on eBay, about $13.65 goes to fees before shipping.
Masterball shows what each card in your collection sold for recently and where, so you can decide which ones are worth listing and which to sell in a lot.
Fees checked November 18, 2026.








