Is your Pokémon card worth grading? The gem rate test

A simple way to decide whether grading a card will pay, using its gem rate, its graded prices and the cost of grading.

Masterball3 min read

A stack of graded Pokémon cards

A card is worth grading when the grade you are likely to get is worth more than the raw card plus the cost of grading. The biggest mistake is looking only at the PSA 10 price and ignoring how rarely that card actually comes back a 10.

The gem rate

The gem rate is the share of graded copies of a card that came back a 10. A card with a 40% gem rate is a very different bet from one with a 2% gem rate, even if both sell for a fortune at PSA 10.

The quick sum

Work out what you would expect to get back:

  1. Chance of a 10 × the PSA 10 price
  2. Chance of a 9 × the PSA 9 price
  3. Everything else × roughly the raw price
  4. Add them up, then take off the grading fee and what the raw card is worth today

If what is left is comfortably above zero, the card is a good candidate.

Gem rate
the number that matters most
PSA 9
is the likely result for most cards
Fees
always come off the top

Long odds look like opportunities

A card that is worth hundreds of times more at PSA 10 can still be a losing bet if only one copy in a hundred makes it. Always look at the odds next to the gain.

Found this useful? Pass it along.
Share
Questions

Frequently asked

  1. The share of all graded copies of a card that received the top grade, a 10.

  2. No. Check how often that card actually comes back a 10. A huge PSA 10 price with a tiny gem rate is usually a losing bet.

What is a gem rate?

The share of all graded copies of a card that received the top grade, a 10.

Keep reading

More from the blog

Every card.Every price.

Scan a card and see what it sells for, raw and graded, from the same sales this blog is written from. Track your whole collection and get told when it moves.

  • Scan
  • Collect
  • Track
  • Grade

Out now on the App Store

Unlimited scanning, free forever!

MasterballFree on iPhoneDownload