PSA vs CGC vs BGS vs SGC vs TAG: which grader for your Pokémon cards

What each major grading company is best at, how their top grades differ and how to choose where to send your cards.

Masterball3 min read

Graded Pokémon cards in their slabs

For most Pokémon cards, PSA brings the highest resale price, CGC is a strong value with a sharp top grade, Beckett is the choice when subgrades matter, SGC is solid in the middle of the market and TAG gives the most precise score. The right one depends on the card and what you plan to do with it.

The five, side by side

CompanyKnown forTop grade to know
PSAThe deepest resale market for PokémonPSA 10 Gem Mint
CGCFast turnaround, consistent gradingCGC 10 Pristine
Beckett (BGS)Subgrades for centering, corners, edges, surfaceBGS 10 Black Label
SGCThe tuxedo holder, strong in the mid marketSGC 10
TAGTechnology-assisted grading with a 1,000-point scoreTAG 10

Why the label matters

A BGS Black Label 10 needs a perfect score on every subgrade and sells for far more than a regular BGS 10. A CGC Pristine 10 sits above a plain CGC 10 in the same way. Masterball prices these labels on their own, because averaging them into a plain 10 would mislead you in both directions.

How to choose

  1. Planning to sell? Check what the card sells for at each company. The gap between graders can be bigger than the gap between grades.
  2. Chasing a perfect card? Beckett and CGC reward truly flawless copies with their top labels.
  3. Building a set? Pick one company and stay with it so the set displays and values consistently.
In the Masterball app

Masterball Premium shows which of your raw cards are likely to be worth grading, using each card’s gem rate and its graded prices.

Found this useful? Pass it along.
Share
Questions

Frequently asked

  1. PSA usually brings the highest resale price, but CGC, Beckett, SGC and TAG each have strengths. Compare what your card sells for at each before you send it.

  2. A Beckett 10 where every subgrade is a perfect 10. It is far rarer and worth much more than a regular BGS 10.

Which grading company is best for Pokémon cards?

PSA usually brings the highest resale price, but CGC, Beckett, SGC and TAG each have strengths. Compare what your card sells for at each before you send it.

Keep reading

More from the blog

Every card.Every price.

Scan a card and see what it sells for, raw and graded, from the same sales this blog is written from. Track your whole collection and get told when it moves.

  • Scan
  • Collect
  • Track
  • Grade

Out now on the App Store

Unlimited scanning, free forever!

MasterballFree on iPhoneDownload